NIMBYism (Not In My Backyard)
Description
Title: The Impactful Phenomenon of NIMBYism (Not In My Backyard)
Definition: NIMBYism, short for the phrase "Not in my backyard," refers to the opposition expressed by a community's residents against new social service developments or housing projects within their locale. This opposition is often born out of fear related to potential decline in property values or a perceived increase in crime rates. NIMBYism can considerably obstruct initiatives to tackle homelessness as it frequently restricts the locations where services like shelters and affordable housing can be established.
Description: NIMBYism reflects a sociopolitical phenomenon where individuals agree with a public project or policy's purpose, but resist its implementation near their own residences. While the push for social service developments and affordable housing is generally understood and supported, when it hits close to home, a different narrative often surfaces. Property owners, in particular, can become fierce oppositionists to such developments, fearing that the proximity of such services or housing options could adversely affect their property’s value or increase their community's crime rates.
Objectives:
- Understand the prevalence and influence of NIMBYism in urban planning and development
- Recognise the relationship between NIMBYism and homelessness
- Mitigate the negative impacts of NIMBYism on affordable housing initiatives
- Foster broad-based community dialogue to overcome NIMBY-related opposition
Mechanisms:
- Exclusionary zoning, where certain services or housing types are prohibited in specific zones
- Defensive localism, which instigates collective action against perceived threats to a locality
- Legislative actions that make it difficult to establish certain facilities in certain areas
Benefits:
- Preservation of property values
- Preservation of community character and amenities
- Protection against perceived increases in crime rates
Challenges:
- Obstruction of social service delivery
- Hindrance to increasing affordable housing availability
- Reinforcement of socio-economic segregations and exclusions
Examples:
1. Opposition to the construction of a halfway house for rehabilitating offenders due to fears of increased crime rates
2. Protests against a proposed homeless shelter in a residential neighborhood due to concern over property value decline
3. Resistance to a low-income housing project in a middle-class neighborhood due to fear of changing the community's character
Further reading:
1. "Understanding NIMBYism": https://shelterforce.org/2017/05/31/understanding-nimbyism/
2. "NIMBYism and the Politics of Locality": https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/mono/10.4324/9781315017884-19/nimbyism-politics-locality-david-howarth